UNPOPULAR OPINION TIME

Bioshock infinite was terrible
As an FPS it's appalling, with little variety between weapons or vigors and hordes of brain-dead bullet sponges to fight. Storywise it's a complete disaster; quite aside from trying to touch on everything from theocracies to manifest destiny to racism to the multiverse, it's not even internally consistent. Elizabeth never makes sense as a character, and neither does the ending. In fact, there's pretty much no redeeming features about the story whatsoever.
So the gameplay is terrible and the story is terrible. That leaves us graphics and soundtrack. Columbia has an awesome visual theme, I'll grant that, though the actual graphics are often quite poor (CONSOLE MAN HERE) The soundtrack is fairly good too. However graphics and soundtrack are by no means as important as gameplay and story, and even if you considered that they were, this would make Infinite at best, an average game, thus deserving a 5.