EmpUbermensch wrote:Wow. This video really taught me a lot, but as I've read through this thread I've felt there's a lot of things I still need to learn... Technical terms, making my own sounds, and a whole host of other things... A problem I have is that I'm naturally a very analytical person, so I find it very easy to over-think things and find mistakes in whatever I'm doing...
...
Well, of course there is still a lot to learn. There will always be stuff to learn, but that shouldn't be something you should be afraid of. Indeed, it can be really frightening to see and/or hear a lot of technical terms we don't understand, but the truth is is that the people uttering those terms only do that so easily because they've probably spent years doing so. They started out without any knowledge of the subject just as anyone else, but they worked hard and studied what they loved.
Being an analytical person is not a problem at all. Actually, I'm convinced that this is a great quality to have. I consider myself to be analytical as well, so I think I might know what you're going through. But you need to realize that being analytical is not a problem. Constantly analyzing, chronically being stuck in the analytical realm, is a problem. Something you also need to realize is that we will constantly come across problems we have to deal with. These are challenges, moments of growth. It's easy to look at them as brick walls, which automatically launches you straight back into the overly analytical (and extremely self conscious) way of thinking. This will only hamper your progress, and thus is not very productive.
Experts only make dealing with problems seem easy because they've basically dealt with similar problems for many years on end, and have developed their own set of tools to deal with said problems.
So you kind of get an anxious reaction when you realize you have a lot of technical jargon to learn? Well, that's entirely reasonable. Would you like to learn some theory? You don't have to go all the way and become a technical genius, you know. Just learn what seems relevant to you right now, and maybe a little more if you're eager to learn. What you want to be aiming at is that whenever you're thinking "Oh man, I have no idea what it means", you'll respond with "I'll look it up right away!" That is, if it seems important to you. There is plenty of learning material out there. Some are really technical and written for experts, but there are also enough books/sites that are really accessible.
Just because you don't know something right now doesn't mean that you won't ever know it. In fact, you can go learn it right now! You will need to put some energy into it, though. But it is not impossible. The thing that makes it possible or not is this question: Do you want to? If that's a yes, then you can achieve it. If it's a no, it's probably not really worth your time (at this moment).
And you know what? You don't have to learn
everything. Not at all! I know my way around theory (I need to with jazz music and all). However, I have this huge binder at home which weighs a ton. That binder is filled with music theory. It probably discusses everything about music and composition. It also goes into composition for orchestras for each single instrument. It is incredibly complex and just looking at that binder makes me cringe. I haven't studied it. Yet. It just doesn't feel relevant to me at this moment in time, and it's a little scary. I'm just not at the point yet where I could seriously study this material, and you know what? That's completely fine. I'll just keep it for later

For now, there are other music theory books that 'resonate' with me a lot more, and I'll study those for the time being! But what's important is that you feel like you're making progress. If you're not entirely clear about what that could be, look out for moments where you start to feel anxious. Then start asking yourself why you're feeling anxious. There's probably a learning experience hidden in there somewhere, but because we analytical types tend to become really self conscious at times we often remain stuck in that anxiety. Take a step back, look at what it is, and what you can do about it. And take baby steps. Putting "Become the next Beethoven" on your to-do list never helped anyone

...
I feel like I'm falling into a trap, though. He talked about how the record dudes wanted him to learn a bunch of technical stuff and it took him forever to make an album... I don't know :/ It's all really overwhelming all of a sudden. My head hurts just thinking about all of it. I'd like to say this video helped (and don't get me wrong, it did), but I also feel like I've been told that if I'm not ready and willing to fully commit myself to making music (which I am not, by any matter of means), then I shouldn't be making music at all. I also see people who have great ears for music, and can actually pick out specific pieces of a song by hearing it, or can actually put down a song they hear on paper or in a DAW and effectively remake a song. I just don't have that ability, and instead of these people inspiring me to get better, they opposite often occurs with me. I always end up comparing myself to them and finding all of my faults, which just generates a greater feeling of helplessness :/
...
Of course it's overwhelming! You're thinking a thousand steps ahead! I think anybody would feel incredibly overwhelmed. You've also got to realize that these lectures are often aimed at people who really want to become a musician no matter what. Often because they've given up on other things or because they simply don't want to do anything but write music. If they get stuck in a rut, that's a disaster for them. So they really have to focus and dedicate their lives to making music.
I can't dedicate myself fully to making music either. I'm studying to become a biology teacher, which is something entirely different. Music is my biggest hobby, my passion if you will, so whenever I have time I try and dedicate some time to music. I can't dedicate my life to music at this point, but what I can do is consistently dedicate some time to it. Both things are ways of investing your time into something you'd want to develop. One way goes all-in, and the other one is more conservative. Just because one can go all-in doesn't necessarily mean he'll create a better album in the end, though.
Even though I can't dedicate my life to making music, I'm completely fine with that. I have other things to do, too! And I like a little variety in my life. I do love making music, however, so I choose to dedicate some time each day to at least try to make progress. Maybe it'll take a little bit longer, but you have to do with what you've got.
You also mention a lot of skills, and that you feel bad for not having them. Like I've said before in a slightly different way: just because you can't do it now doesn't mean you'll never be able to do it. All skills can be practised, and through consistent practise eventually you become skilled. Some people seem to be born with some kind of talent, but that doesn't mean you can't get there. And realize that simply having skills doesn't guarantee success.
We all constantly find faults in ourselves, especially us self conscious analytical folk. What you need to try next time is look at what that fault is. What is it, and what can I do right now to work on that? Under-developed hearing? Look up ways to train your ear. Use a web-app. Close your eyes and play major and minor chords on an instrument and listen very carefully. Play scales and hum along with them, try to predict them. When you're showering randomly sing a scale. Listen to your favourite songs and really listen to them. What do you like about those songs?
(Here's a good program, by the way:
http://www.miles.be/software/34-functio ... trainer-v2 - It runs on Adobe AIR, so be sure to have that installed)
Wow, I feel like I've written a book. I think it's probably best to end the post right here and get back to my studies

I've got plenty of schoolwork to do, but if I do this now I know I'll have more free time later today I can spend on making music

So hey, keep your head up, put your hoof down and look for solutions
I do hope there's some value in my post... It's so long D: