by Guthey » 30 Jan 2014 21:50
First off, I compliment you on your voice, second, that autotune... *shiver*. I just think autotune ruins the initial voice. Anyways, Since you're the singer, I guess I critique your singing. Well, I'm not a singer, so I don't know what to really say other than that your singing was pretty good, to me at least. And if you were trying to sound like snob, then I'd say you certainly knocked it out of the park, not to insult your voice if it just sounds like that. The way the actual music goes seems sort of strange, though. The beat seems a little off beat, maybe just a 1-2 step would suffice, the variation in the beat just seemed unnecessary. and the bass melody and guitar melody doesn't seem to fit the "groove," per-say, of the song. I'd actually stay to the higher end of the spectrum, rather than the low end. the song, to me, seems like a sort of popy type of song, so I think it should feel a little more cheery. I think the melody at :36 to its end should be the initial lead or groove to the song. Because, the beginning of the song sounds, like, normal, but then when the bassline comes in, it sort of takes a different feel like the song is going to go off in a different direction. I'm not too good with this genre, so that's kind of why I have trouble establishing my opinion.