A Zebra's Loneliness:Okay, I think I hear clipping even in the very beginning. I like the bass, but it's pretty overpowering, plus it sounds kind of like a preset. Alright, it gets repetitive, pretty fast. That synth that comes in just before 1:00 is just... meh. It's out of place, it doesn't fit the mood. The drums entrance came too late into the song, but the drums themselves are good. The main problem here is it's basically the same thing through the entire song. It's really monotone, you need to have multiple sections that are notably different from one another. Plus, it sounds like there is little to no mixing, but for a first song it's completely understandable.
Aperture Ponies:That choppy supersaw, it's... well, choppy. Try to make it more legato. The drums are pretty good again. Some of the sounds, are still pretty meh, and some sound like presets. Try and steer clear from presets, it's okay once in a while, but you won't learn proper sound design by using them. At 1:25ish there is a sound that sounds almost completely panned to the left, and honestly, it just sounds ugly. Like with the last song, it's repetitive and monotone. You have the same pattern going on in the back for the entire thing, and it gets incredibly tiring to listen to after a while. Just try to include more variation.
To War:Okay the arps are cool, and I like the snare pattern. Okay it just went from having a completely orchestral feel to having a random electronic lead come out of nowhere. And now the orchestral feel is back. Okay, this one's a bit less repetitive. If you're going for an orchestral piece, minimize the electronic stuff, because the electronic arpeggios feels really out of place. See, now it's back into a repetitive melody loop. There is no significant change of mood, like most orchestral pieces have. Plus, the snare pattern is absolutely alone. There is no aux percussion, no cymbals, no mallets, and it's the same snare pattern over and over. There actually isn't too many other concert instruments either, so next time for orchestral, try adding more percussion, low brass, woodwinds, and try to stay away from the electronic stuff. The outro was weak on this one, it goes from being in full swing to over in the course of a short time.
Pinkie Pie's Welcome Rave (itroitnyah is right, use a less generic title)
:The intro arps are almost too fast. The supersaw sounds really weak. The arps need to be lower, they're taking up a lot of room in the mix. You did a better job making it less monotone, but the sound design, is pretty... well, bad here. The really heavy bass at like 1:17 is really overpowering, it takes over the entire song during that portion. Some of the patterns don't really match up too well. When the chiptuney synth is soloed, it feels really empty. The kick is doing a 4x4 beat almost the entire thing, and it's nearly inaudible. You should probably sidechain it, it makes it more noticeable, and it's pretty easy to do in most DAWs. Overall, everything fought for space, it needs to be mixed, otherwise, everything just sounds like it's fighting for room to breathe.
Overall:A lot of them sound really monotone/repetitive. It's kinda like you layed down one pattern, or melody, or chord progression, and just formed a song around that one thing. Don't think it's just you, because a lot of people have this problem. The other thing I can't emphasize enough: how important it is to learn how to mix/master along with sound design. Those are probably the most important things you need to know, as they can make a
serious difference in production quality. Sound design is really important to learn, it's good to make sure all of your sounds fit together, otherwise you'll get stuff that seems really out of place. Plus, your sound design habits will probably lead into developing a distinct style. The other thing, like I said is mixing, you
NEED to learn how to mix. All of these songs were clipping in quite a few places. A pretty good mixing tactic is to mix everything down really far (usually like -4dB at least), so you've got some space to adjust levels. Watch a few tutorials on mixing, it'll help a lot.
Okay, I think I'm about done here, so welcome to MLR! Hope I helped you!
