Rainbowdutch wrote:Rainbowjack and dodo
Here are the problems I have with your site and your contest
- Like bartekko said, the >24 hour thing is kind of a big problem no matter how much you two try to steer around the subjects in your replies.
- Also should there be a way to correct the mistakes of someone else. Mistakes are human and on a professional site they should be fixed as soon as possible.
- The writing of your site is very casual as well. They look like the average tumblr post of a brony musician, I would suggest looking at how equestria daily does its writeup.
- The centered text is also difficult to read. I again would like to refer to equestria daily for tips.
- I read some of your posts and especially when it comes to the reviews I would suggest to actually know what you are talking about. I am not even talking about all the technical details when it comes to making music but " I've recently listened to "Stuck in Time" by the Living Tombstone, a rock song he collaborated on with another musician about Doctor Whooves." Made me facepalm the hardest. Not only is bronyfied an established musician in the fandom, when you are doing a review of a song you should at least know who the musician is.
- the remix wars is also a well known contest that is organized by mlr. I would suggest changing the name of yours to prevent any confusion. Right now it looks like you are leeching of the fame of an already well known event by using its name.
- on a personal note I am really questioning the quality controll of your contest. From reading those reviews I really discourage using your own people for this. The mlr remix war is in good hands b
ecause I know makkon's judgement is professional and not biased. God, I suspect that there would be tons of people who would be willing to help him like "professional" brony musicians and prelisteners for equestria daily (including me). But I really don't think that you guys can get "a thelivingtombstone" or "a micthemicrophone" on board to judge the songs or that you can get one of them as far as to collab with the winner.