BeaM wrote:This. I've been on this site since around January this year and I have yet to produce. A. Single. Song.
I try to make songs and stuff but I get stuck somewhere around the sound design/melodies phase of it. I'm trying to dedicate my life to music but it's hard to do
If you go onto a group musician chat and expect it to be related about music, or to find help with music, you're going to have a bad time.
3) The chat is for music discussion. Silliness is tolerated lightly, but if you want to talk about unrelated things, please seek another chat room.
Navron wrote:Also, I'm not trying to get into a pissing match. If anything, the feedback issue was more of what prompted the thread in the first place, and that's when I noticed that there's A LOT of people active on the forums that don't seem that interested in discussing music.
Navron wrote:@itroitnyah, BeaM, and soultensionbenjamin:
If this were any other music production forum, anybody posting a vague or off-topic reply to a serious question of production would likely get banned, or at the least, their reply deleted.
Somebody asking a serious question shouldn't have to wade through 30+ replies to see the 3 good replies that directly relate to the question.
the4thImpulse wrote:Maybe if the admin here makes a rule where you can not start threads in the music section until you reach a set post count (let them respond to threads but not start them). Combine that with more of a crackdown on spam and useless chatter threads like "the real names thread" from the mods (which we need more of).
I think there either needs to be a subforum for spam and the 'worthless chatter' or NO thread at all for spam of any kind, leave in in skype groups or go to another brony forum. I would rather there be none at all but it seems that the community subforum is for worthless chatter.
Not intending any disrespect, but there is nothing on there about discussing music. I'd be perfectly fine with a subforum designated for specifically topics of that nature though.Sports, politics, movies, videogames, questionable hobbies, photos from your family vacation, etc. Talk about stuff! But do try to stay on topic.
Assuming I was always active since the day I joined...Navron wrote:@itroitnyah, BeaM, and soultensionbenjamin:
All of you post less than 2 posts per day on average. There's a big difference between lurking the site to read up on topics, and thinking the site is a social network.
Navron wrote:Somebody asking a serious question shouldn't have to wade through 30+ replies to see the 3 good replies that directly relate to the question.
Nine Volt wrote:Not intending any disrespect, but there is nothing on there about discussing music. I'd be perfectly fine with a subforum designated for specifically topics of that nature though.
With regards to the music thing, the set post count could be a good idea, I'd support it.
And yes, we still need more mods.
the4thImpulse wrote:Nine Volt wrote:Not intending any disrespect, but there is nothing on there about discussing music. I'd be perfectly fine with a subforum designated for specifically topics of that nature though.
With regards to the music thing, the set post count could be a good idea, I'd support it.
And yes, we still need more mods.
I personally have a lot of trouble with language skills so I know people will take what I write the wrong way sometimes so let me try to explain that better. The community thread is for discussions, I know that and I don't want to change that. But, there are a lot of off topics posts in many of those threads, sometimes I really don't see the need for a certain thread but that's not for me to judge.
To be absolutely clear, the community section has a lot of the off topic/spamy stuff we are all sick of here. If a thread is about your favorite car that's not the place to show off your favorite pony meme and leave the thread derailed. IMO there's a lot of chat threads that don't serve much purpose in helping the music community grow for the better, if anything its only helped grow the 'chat room' habits that have leaked out all across the board.
I hope that makes better sense, if not please ignore what I have wrote on that specific subject.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 14 guests